Wine, Ribs, and Rustic Charm: Your Ideal Monterey Date Night Awaits

Summer evenings in Monterey are meant for slowing down, savoring good food, and sharing moments with someone special. Whether visiting the Central Coast for a romantic getaway or looking to make a regular weeknight feel extraordinary, there’s no better backdrop than the warm, rustic ambiance of Tarpy’s. Nestled in a historic stone house surrounded by lush gardens, Tarpy’s sets the stage for a truly memorable date night.

From hand-cut USDA Prime steaks to smoky, fall-off-the-bone ribs and expertly paired wines, every detail is crafted to delight. Here’s how to plan a flawless date night, complete with bold flavors, inviting spaces, and that unmistakable Monterey charm.

Set the Mood: Rustic Elegance in a Garden Setting

Tarpy’s is more than just a restaurant—it’s an experience. The property’s rich history, combined with handcrafted architecture and 3.5 acres of gardens, offers a cozy and elegant atmosphere that feels worlds away from the everyday.

Choose a quiet table on one of the stone patios, framed by flickering lanterns and climbing ivy. Prefer something more intimate indoors? The warm tones, exposed beams, and nooks throughout the dining room create just the right setting for relaxed connection and conversation.

Start with Something to Share

The perfect evening begins with a few bites to whet the appetite—and Tarpy’s appetizer menu is made for sharing. Choose a mix of comforting and bold flavors to kick things off.

Date Night Starters

1. Dungeness & Blue Crab Cakes: Delicate yet rich, these are served with a roasted pepper coriander cream that brings depth and color to the plate.
2. Spicy Tuna Tacos: A fresh and flavorful choice with ponzu aioli, sesame seeds, and a gentle heat from wasabi tobiko.
3. Bruschetta: Toasted bread layered with herbed goat cheese, roasted garlic, and blistered tomatoes—ideal with a chilled glass of rosé.
4. Fried Artichoke Hearts: Served with Srirachanaise and ranch, these are crispy, golden, and full of flavor—perfect for two.

Feeling festive? A Giant Bavarian Pretzel with ale-cheddar and whole-grain mustard adds a playful touch to the evening.

Go Bold: Ribs, Steaks, and Classic Favorites

When it comes to entrées, Tarpy’s is known for its expertly prepared meats and seasonal California fare. The menu highlights dishes that balance rustic comfort with culinary sophistication—especially ideal for date night.

Signature Entrées to Savor Together

1. Smoked Baby Back Ribs: Available as a half or full rack, these are glazed to perfection and served with dill-chive potato salad and horseradish slaw. Smoky, tender, and just the right amount of indulgent.
2. Rib Eye (USDA Prime): A 14oz cut, fire-grilled and paired with roasted marble potatoes and broccolini. Finished with a black pepper demi-glaze for a rich, peppery finish.
3. Filet Mignon (USDA Prime): A refined and tender 8oz cut with Brussels sprouts, mushrooms, and beef jus—an elegant choice for a special evening.
4. Angus Sirloin Chateau: This USDA Prime steak is served with gorgonzola spinach and roasted garlic mashed potatoes, finished with a black pepper thyme demi-glaze.

Prefer something other than beef? The Center Cut Bone-In Pork Chop with herbed polenta, apple compote, and bacon Brussels sprouts is a delicious alternative with warm, comforting notes.

Enhance the Experience with Wine

A thoughtfully chosen glass of wine can elevate any dish and bring another layer of enjoyment to the table. Tarpy’s wine list includes selections from both nearby vineyards and international producers, giving couples plenty to explore.

Recommended Pairings

1. Cabernet Sauvignon from Justin (Paso Robles): Bold and structured, ideal with a ribeye or pork chop.
2. Zinfandel from ThreadCount by Quilt: Spicy and fruit-forward, a great companion to smoked ribs or short ribs.
3. Chardonnay from Post & Beam by Far Niente: Buttery and smooth, excellent with halibut or rich starters like crab cakes.
4. Pinot Noir from Loring Wine Co.: Balanced and earthy—pairs well with filet mignon, mushroom dishes, or even a Fuji Apple salad.

Looking to toast the evening? Choose from Prosecco by Zonin or Moet Brut Rosé for a celebratory splash of bubbles.

For a Non-Traditional Twist: Cocktails That Spark Connection

Tarpy’s cocktail menu blends creativity with seasonal ingredients. These handcrafted drinks make a great first impression and are a fun way to try something new together.

Cocktails for Two

1. Strawberry Bourbon Fling: Sweet, tart, and a little smoky—this one is made with Elijah Craig bourbon, elderflower, and strawberry syrup.
2. The Ruby: A vibrant, citrus-forward drink with vodka, St. Germain, Aperol, and aquafaba. Elegant and beautifully balanced.
3. Ocean Strike: Blue spirulina gives this gin-based cocktail a stunning hue, while Italicus and lemon add complexity. Bonus: $1 from every drink supports local charities.
4. Tarpy’s Mule: With Buffalo Trace, mint-cinnamon syrup, and ginger beer, this take on a classic mule is refreshing and bold.

Mocktails and non-alcoholic options like Guava Tea, Lemonberry, or Tropical Black Tea are also available for a lighter approach to the evening.

Don’t Skip the Side Conversation

Complement the main course with sides that encourage sharing and add richness to the meal.

1. Gruyère Scalloped Potatoes: Creamy and comforting—ideal alongside a grilled steak.
2. Brussels Sprouts: Crisped to perfection with a hint of char, these make an excellent savory addition.
3. Gorgonzola Spinach: Velvety and decadent, this is a go-to for fans of bold cheese flavors.
4. Tarpy’s Steak Fries: A classic choice that brings familiarity and crunch.

Make It Last: A Place to Linger and Connect

At Tarpy’s, there’s no rush. Date night here is about enjoying the pace, the setting, and the company. Guests are welcome to linger over that final glass of wine, watch the sunset dip behind the trees, or stroll through the gardens after dinner.

Looking to extend the experience? Tarpy’s also offers happy hour menus, private event spaces, and seasonal specials throughout the summer. Whether it’s a first date, a long-overdue evening out, or a celebration of something more, this is a place where memories are made.

Create the summer evening you won’t forget. Reserve your date night at Tarpy’s today.

Restaurant Name: Tarpy’s

Location: Monterey, CA

Phone number: 831.647.1444